Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kevin Thuot's avatar

I do find the idea funny in a dark/absurd way that a wave of AI slop will perversely come to rescue us from our current social media hell, by swamping all the human voices screaming at each other.

The upshot being no one likes the social media anymore because everything is swarming with bots and we end up with more face to face interaction.

Expand full comment
Neal Rauhauser's avatar

While all of the anecdotes in here are true and skepticism of AI is warranted, I have an anecdote of my own to offer.

I've had complex health problems since catching Lyme disease in 2007. There has been a shifting diagnosis over the years, for which counter-measures sorta helped ... somewhat.

I had surgery at the start of July and during the recovery time I started playing with Claude Desktop, feeding it information on my symptoms. I have a computer science education, this effort blossomed into a health diary app. Since I don't trust any LLM further than I can throw an Nvidia RTX 5090, I used a knowledge graph extension, and fed it a dozen health care provider articles from PubMed Central. The LLM can write English, but they'll lie at the drop of a hat. If you constrain them with actual expert knowledge, the results are less untrustworthy.

I was logging every bit of food, meds, and supplements I took. I gave it my blood work. I started logging blood pressure. I used Claude Code to create a method of extracting the data from my Garmin fitness monitor.

And out of this effort, wherein an LLM was constrained on all sides by tabular data and expert opinions, it spit out an acronym for a health condition. I ticked every checkbox for this, the OTC solutions for it are working, and I've begun the process of getting a formal diagnosis, which comes with some prescription tools for limiting the trouble I face.

None of that would have happened without AI, but I didn't treat a bare LLM like an oracle, I made it do my bidding. This is how things are going to be, albeit running on whatever is still standing after the insane AI bubble we are in finally bursts.

Expand full comment
175 more comments...

No posts