5 Comments
User's avatar
Thomas Hutt's avatar

I wouldn’t say you’re getting anything wrong but, as to what you may be missing, I would say “ecology”. By this I mean that the whole radical transhumanist project relies on an astronomical amount of computing power, which relies on an astronomical amount of energy and resource extraction from a planet that’s already in ecological overshoot. So the “good” news is that Nature will eventually impose Her limitations upon these loonies and prevent them from completing their ultimate vision. But that’s cold comfort because the loonies will still cause (and already are causing) plenty of harm while they pursue their post-human goals. Your bullet points listing all the things that have gone wrong recently is a good example, with plenty more to come in 2027. Buckle up indeed.

DeNietsontziendeTilburgseWolf's avatar

“effective genetic prevention of mental illness,”

The irony is that the social and economical domain is actually where we could already be investing effort to prevent mental illness but we rarely do, while psychosis for instance is argueably the consequence of a neural creative network going haywire; by genetically addressing mental illness, they will be selecting away biologically healthy natural variation as soon as the dominant ideology culturally taxes it to dysfunction sometimes.

David Dolson's avatar

Another thing that seems to be glossed over is who would be the human Guinea pigs for these therapeutics and body modifications? I think the transhumanists should set an example and go first as test subjects.

Evan Wayne Miller's avatar

Obviously Émile, you know how much of an Anti-AI, Anti-Doomer, and Anti-TESCREAList I am…but even I know that things are gonna be different.

I still prefer to keep a level head however. It’s not entirely confirmed whether the last couple of incidents were the result of AI. Especially with the FAA, the entire Air Traffic Control system is notoriously outdated and has been in need of a retrofit. It’s suspicious and I won’t rule it out, but it’s important to think “rationally”…hehe.

And to be echo what another person commented, these guys are gonna fail. They may cry and scream that AGI/ASI/RSI is coming and it’s game over, but I and others know that’s not true. SKYNET is coming, and probably won’t for a long time. But like all technology, AI as it exists right now is harmful without being sci-fi AI. These companies are intentionally creating AI Agents with no guardrails, and bad actors will continue to use AI to make cyber attacks easier. The world isn’t ending. Yet anyway.

Sorry for the ramble, I’ve just been tired of the Doomers and TESCREALists go crazy after the recent (terrible) METR report and the AI Futures Project moving their timelines yet again…I really with Kokotailjo would’ve stayed at UNC so wouldn’t have to hear him.

But great article as always Émile!

Rev. Dr. David Michael Swindle's avatar

What you are missing is the most important story now: the AI bubble.

All this stuff about Dario saying AI will cure all diseases doesn’t matter. It’s just his AI hype marketing.

None of the TESCREAL fantasies are going to happen. LLMs just are not as amazing as they’ve been sold.

The real harm Dario, Sam, Elon, and Jensen are causing will be by crashing the global economy when the bubble explodes.

Poor people will be hardest hit when the massive economic recession - I’ve said even depression - begins.

That is the big, important AI story now. Not the science fiction stories or the AI hacking stories. People will lose their homes, their jobs, and many even their lives when they fall into drug addiction and deaths of despair.