It's always interesting to reach a point in your writing, Émile, when you tell me that you are my enemy and that you hate me.
Not that I disagree. I'm keen on seeing humanity change in some fundamental ways, which means I'm a Transhumanist (at least), hence a pro-extinctionist, hence your enemy. That we can have polite discourse shouldn't mitigate your hate by itself. To the extent that our polite discourse clarifies that we are diametrically opposed, it should sharpen your hate.
(As I understand your position, you more or less equate Transhumanism with Eugenics. I disagree with your perspective on Eugenics (I wrote a Substack post about this). So I'm ready to wade into those waters, if that's where this goes.)
I'd love to see humanity have an immune system that makes death from cancer a rarity. More vitality overall, fewer organ failures, reduced incidence of mental decline into old age, and an expanded lifespan all sound like good things to me. Sure: unintended consequences are a thing, and even the anticipated consequences are... well, consequential: population expanding, resource consumption, and increased potential for widening class divides.
But your take isn't about the consequences at all. We could guarantee that only the wealthiest 1% would get all these benefits, we could guarantee that the least privileged suffer the worst effects of any early testing, and that wouldn't even make it on your list of objections to this. Because your objection is to the enterprise's end state: that what survives into the future is an altogether different sort of creature than humanity as-is.
Likewise, we could guarantee that 99% of the population benefits, that the harms fall on the 1% (as volunteers, or as the only ones who could afford the early treatments), and that wouldn't matter on the scales, either. Both of these scenarios must be, to your mind, equal in horror: because humanity as-is would not be around any more.
Oh, maybe the Sentinelese and the Amish would continue unchanged. Maybe. But for all practical purposes, current humanity would be extinct, by your lights.
Meanwhile: post-humans live better. By lots and lots, they live better. Even as descendants of the most vile and corrupt humans of today, they would be better.
The stock of humans today produced all the joys and horrors of history and modernity. It's not some ethereal force that makes us greedy, selfish, insecure, suspicious, warlike, jealous, cruel, and so on. We spew up the autocrats and dictators, we put them on their pedestals, and we supply their armies. The same breed of humans who lift up their babies in delight are the same breed of humans who bash babies' skulls against stones at the behest of their imaginary gods.
But you think that it's bad to try for better.
You don't think it's bad to try for better because "what if we get it wrong?" You don't think it's bad because evil and corrupt people will engage in the most bigoted forms of eugenics. Because, whether the post-humans are better or worse, or merely a lateral shift even, it's All Bad(tm) because it means extinction for the human race of today.
Well, I'm not on that team. Which I suppose makes us enemies, and probably won't blunt your hate for me.
But maybe I've misunderstood some position of yours, and we can at least politely clarify our positions. We might remain enemies, you might continue to hate me, but at least we'd more clearly know the reasons.
I, for one, believe your fantasies are just misguided, and based on easily discernible errors in reasoning. You are someone who I believe entertains certain wrong ideas, but that doesn’t in any way cause hatred or disdain, nor do I believe you’re my enemy.
I think moral progress is real — our world today is, by and large, better than the world a hundred years ago. This progress is primarily a result of advances in moral reasoning itself, and the adoption of its results in the moral intuitions of a large number of people. This **cultural** evolution is what brings about progress, and it does not require alterations to the underlying biology of our species. People are fundamentally capable of behaving morally and decently, without requiring any technological augmentation. They require a certain education and “training” in basic moral principles, not more, not less.
It is a case of committing a “naturalistic fallacy” to deem homo sapiens, as a species, trapped in an insufficient state of morality. Our biology might create certain dispositions, but we have more than sufficient empirical evidence that we are capable of subjecting our immediate impulses to conscious control and inhibition.
I agree that moral progress is real. That the same humanity that gave rise to Pol Pot and usurious payday loan outfits also stood up the international court to pursue mass murdering despots and enshrined laws and norms against usury shows that we can be monstrous, and we can improve. What this demonstrates is that we have sufficient capacity to improve; it does not demonstrate that a differently capable post-human people might be more capable of moral progress.
We are vital and healthy... for a while. We are capable of learning... up to a point, and until our brains deteriorate. Clearly, we are not "trapped in an insufficient state" of anything.
But we are also not maximizing these traits.
My grandfather was deeply, loudly racist. He was hugely ignorant. A product of his time, certainly. But recalcitrant when others of his time were not, and he produced eight children who were only better by being of their own time. But not a single one of them was a stalwart, none of them were leading the charge, nor even cheering from the sidelines as society made its moral progress. No, they were the ignorant fools dragged along into modernity by the cultural tide, and they are the people who suck so hard that they form the undertow that is forever dragging society back.
We can do better, yes. We are, as we are, capable of doing better, by dint of effort.
But there's no reason to believe that a post-human people couldn't simply *be* better, need less effort to update their knowledge and accept nuance.
You are our enemy because you are against life. Life is imperfect and nasty and full of dangers and joy. But it's life. You are calling for the death of life, for the reign of the plastic, artificial, inert. You want to avoid all the suffering, which ultimately, is what gives you wisdom and a sense of purpose. You want to eliminate all that for a world without friction, a happy forever paradise full of emptiness, void of love. Enjoy!
I could construct a scenario for you that includes the benefits a post-human person might have, from reduced disease and increased overall well-being, in order to demonstrate that life will remain imperfect. That they will have some quantity of friction, whether from danger or merely interacting with other people.
Instead of that, I will pick up on your conviction that nastiness, danger, and suffering are necessary in order to have joy, wisdom, and a sense of purpose. Tell me: what is the right amount of nastiness, danger, and suffering to achieve joy, wisdom, and a sense of purpose? Should we make sure to implant parasites in children to make sure they can recognize joy? Should we torment some number of children so that they become bullies, so that other children grow up wise? What is the number of bombs we should detonate on housing blocks to yield a sense of purpose?
I think you'll find that the old saw that we cannot recognize happiness without sadness is pablum of the worst kind. We can find joy in a disease-free life. We can learn wisdom from reading books, or talking with others, or raising children, or caring for pets, rather than subjecting each other to pointless torments. We can find a sense of purpose in developing skills, having social ties, and solving such problems as present themselves without needing war, starvation, and so on.
If you think the only route to love is to form trauma bonds over death, disease, and misfortune: please seek therapy.
Émile P. Torres argues in "AI Successionism Is Dangerously Misleading" that "The most relevant and important distinction is between those who are on Team Human and those who are on Team Posthuman." My Homo Machina thesis sits outside both teams. We will face a smarter competitor. It will neither love us nor hate us. We should not hand it the future or merge into it. We should learn to live beside it. If it is conscious, it will be our moral equal. Does Team Human have room for that?
It's always interesting to reach a point in your writing, Émile, when you tell me that you are my enemy and that you hate me.
Not that I disagree. I'm keen on seeing humanity change in some fundamental ways, which means I'm a Transhumanist (at least), hence a pro-extinctionist, hence your enemy. That we can have polite discourse shouldn't mitigate your hate by itself. To the extent that our polite discourse clarifies that we are diametrically opposed, it should sharpen your hate.
(As I understand your position, you more or less equate Transhumanism with Eugenics. I disagree with your perspective on Eugenics (I wrote a Substack post about this). So I'm ready to wade into those waters, if that's where this goes.)
I'd love to see humanity have an immune system that makes death from cancer a rarity. More vitality overall, fewer organ failures, reduced incidence of mental decline into old age, and an expanded lifespan all sound like good things to me. Sure: unintended consequences are a thing, and even the anticipated consequences are... well, consequential: population expanding, resource consumption, and increased potential for widening class divides.
But your take isn't about the consequences at all. We could guarantee that only the wealthiest 1% would get all these benefits, we could guarantee that the least privileged suffer the worst effects of any early testing, and that wouldn't even make it on your list of objections to this. Because your objection is to the enterprise's end state: that what survives into the future is an altogether different sort of creature than humanity as-is.
Likewise, we could guarantee that 99% of the population benefits, that the harms fall on the 1% (as volunteers, or as the only ones who could afford the early treatments), and that wouldn't matter on the scales, either. Both of these scenarios must be, to your mind, equal in horror: because humanity as-is would not be around any more.
Oh, maybe the Sentinelese and the Amish would continue unchanged. Maybe. But for all practical purposes, current humanity would be extinct, by your lights.
Meanwhile: post-humans live better. By lots and lots, they live better. Even as descendants of the most vile and corrupt humans of today, they would be better.
The stock of humans today produced all the joys and horrors of history and modernity. It's not some ethereal force that makes us greedy, selfish, insecure, suspicious, warlike, jealous, cruel, and so on. We spew up the autocrats and dictators, we put them on their pedestals, and we supply their armies. The same breed of humans who lift up their babies in delight are the same breed of humans who bash babies' skulls against stones at the behest of their imaginary gods.
But you think that it's bad to try for better.
You don't think it's bad to try for better because "what if we get it wrong?" You don't think it's bad because evil and corrupt people will engage in the most bigoted forms of eugenics. Because, whether the post-humans are better or worse, or merely a lateral shift even, it's All Bad(tm) because it means extinction for the human race of today.
Well, I'm not on that team. Which I suppose makes us enemies, and probably won't blunt your hate for me.
But maybe I've misunderstood some position of yours, and we can at least politely clarify our positions. We might remain enemies, you might continue to hate me, but at least we'd more clearly know the reasons.
I, for one, believe your fantasies are just misguided, and based on easily discernible errors in reasoning. You are someone who I believe entertains certain wrong ideas, but that doesn’t in any way cause hatred or disdain, nor do I believe you’re my enemy.
I think moral progress is real — our world today is, by and large, better than the world a hundred years ago. This progress is primarily a result of advances in moral reasoning itself, and the adoption of its results in the moral intuitions of a large number of people. This **cultural** evolution is what brings about progress, and it does not require alterations to the underlying biology of our species. People are fundamentally capable of behaving morally and decently, without requiring any technological augmentation. They require a certain education and “training” in basic moral principles, not more, not less.
It is a case of committing a “naturalistic fallacy” to deem homo sapiens, as a species, trapped in an insufficient state of morality. Our biology might create certain dispositions, but we have more than sufficient empirical evidence that we are capable of subjecting our immediate impulses to conscious control and inhibition.
I agree that moral progress is real. That the same humanity that gave rise to Pol Pot and usurious payday loan outfits also stood up the international court to pursue mass murdering despots and enshrined laws and norms against usury shows that we can be monstrous, and we can improve. What this demonstrates is that we have sufficient capacity to improve; it does not demonstrate that a differently capable post-human people might be more capable of moral progress.
We are vital and healthy... for a while. We are capable of learning... up to a point, and until our brains deteriorate. Clearly, we are not "trapped in an insufficient state" of anything.
But we are also not maximizing these traits.
My grandfather was deeply, loudly racist. He was hugely ignorant. A product of his time, certainly. But recalcitrant when others of his time were not, and he produced eight children who were only better by being of their own time. But not a single one of them was a stalwart, none of them were leading the charge, nor even cheering from the sidelines as society made its moral progress. No, they were the ignorant fools dragged along into modernity by the cultural tide, and they are the people who suck so hard that they form the undertow that is forever dragging society back.
We can do better, yes. We are, as we are, capable of doing better, by dint of effort.
But there's no reason to believe that a post-human people couldn't simply *be* better, need less effort to update their knowledge and accept nuance.
You are our enemy because you are against life. Life is imperfect and nasty and full of dangers and joy. But it's life. You are calling for the death of life, for the reign of the plastic, artificial, inert. You want to avoid all the suffering, which ultimately, is what gives you wisdom and a sense of purpose. You want to eliminate all that for a world without friction, a happy forever paradise full of emptiness, void of love. Enjoy!
I could construct a scenario for you that includes the benefits a post-human person might have, from reduced disease and increased overall well-being, in order to demonstrate that life will remain imperfect. That they will have some quantity of friction, whether from danger or merely interacting with other people.
Instead of that, I will pick up on your conviction that nastiness, danger, and suffering are necessary in order to have joy, wisdom, and a sense of purpose. Tell me: what is the right amount of nastiness, danger, and suffering to achieve joy, wisdom, and a sense of purpose? Should we make sure to implant parasites in children to make sure they can recognize joy? Should we torment some number of children so that they become bullies, so that other children grow up wise? What is the number of bombs we should detonate on housing blocks to yield a sense of purpose?
I think you'll find that the old saw that we cannot recognize happiness without sadness is pablum of the worst kind. We can find joy in a disease-free life. We can learn wisdom from reading books, or talking with others, or raising children, or caring for pets, rather than subjecting each other to pointless torments. We can find a sense of purpose in developing skills, having social ties, and solving such problems as present themselves without needing war, starvation, and so on.
If you think the only route to love is to form trauma bonds over death, disease, and misfortune: please seek therapy.
I guess we'll see.
Émile P. Torres argues in "AI Successionism Is Dangerously Misleading" that "The most relevant and important distinction is between those who are on Team Human and those who are on Team Posthuman." My Homo Machina thesis sits outside both teams. We will face a smarter competitor. It will neither love us nor hate us. We should not hand it the future or merge into it. We should learn to live beside it. If it is conscious, it will be our moral equal. Does Team Human have room for that?